Thursday, February 26, 2015

Week 7: A Ghost Took Over My Life (Storytelling)

I stood before a group of cow herders. One sat in a rickety chair, while the others stood in a semi-circle behind him. To my right stood a man who looked identical to me, behind us stood my mother and wife, the two people this man stole from me.

“Neat-Herd King,” I addressed the young man sitting in the chair, “this man has stolen my life and claims to be me. If I tell you what happened, will you decide which of us is the true Brahman and end this madness?”

“I will,” he said. “Please, tell your story.”
Illustration by Warwick Goble from Folk-Tales of Bengal 
And so I began:

Have you ever gone away for a few years and come back to find a ghost living your life? I’m gonna guess you haven’t. Well, I've lived this nightmare and now I want my family back. But let me start from the beginning, just so you know I’m the real Brahman.

I was poor and couldn't support my wife and mother on the money I had. So I decided to travel to a distant land to work and earn enough money for us to live off. I knew I’d be gone for a while and I told my wife and mother this.

Leaving them was the hardest thing I've ever had to do, but I knew that without money we wouldn't survive. So I hugged my mother and kissed my wife and set off on the great journey. I worked for years, saving everything I made. Finally, I knew I had enough money to give my family a comfortable life.

When I returned, I was so excited to see my wife and mother. I couldn't wait to show them the money I had made and buy them new clothes and the best food. But things did not go as I planned. I came back, and there was a man inside the house…a man who looked exactly like me.
I was looking at a living reflection of myself who had lived with my family the years I was away. I was shocked and couldn't understand what happened.

“What are you doing here? This is my house!” I shouted at the man.

He looked me over and smirked, just a little. “No,” he said. “This is my house. This is my wife and this is my mother. I've lived here for years and now you just come here and claim it all for yourself? No. This is my family.”

I stared at the imposter who had taken over my life. After years of hard work, I come to find my life is being lived by someone else. I decided to bring the matter before the King of our kingdom. If anyone could discover the truth and give me my life back it was him.

Of course, the King was just as vexed as I. When I brought the look-alike to court to plead my case, he simply stared between the two of us, not knowing what to do. Finally he said he’d decide tomorrow. And then he said the next day, and then next.

As I was leaving the King’s court one day, a herdsman called me over. He said the Neat-Herd King would decide the case if the real King said it was all right. When I asked the King, he eagerly gave the responsibility over to the cow herder.
*** 

“And now, I am here, pleading my case to you, Neat-Herd King,” I said, watching the Cow Herder King look between the imposter and me.

“Well,” the herder said as he stood from his chair. He grabbed a small bottle from one of the men behind him. “This is what we’ll do. Whoever can get inside this bottle will be the man who keeps the home, wife, and mother.”

I stared at the cow herder incredulously. “What do you mean!?” I shouted. “It’s impossible! Even a herder should know that!”

The imposter jumped at his opportunity. “Of course I can do that,” he said. Before I could blink, the man transformed from my double into a small bug and flew into the bottle.

I was about to despair. I thought this cow herder was going to give this fake my family  for flying in a bottle. But the Neat-Herd King quickly took a cap and sealed the bottle.

“Of course it’s impossible,” the Herder King said, “at least for a real human.” He smiled at me and gestured to my wife and mother. “This is your real son and husband. The other was a ghost who tricked you. It happened to me once before.” The Herder King handed me the bottle, which held the small bug the ghost had transformed into. “He can’t escape as long as you keep the bottle sealed,” the Neat-Herd King said.

I took the bottle from him and nodded. “Thank you. I doubted you, but you are true and clever.” With the bottle in one hand, I rejoined my family who began crying and hugging me. Finally life could go back to normal.
***

Author's Note: My retelling this week is from the Bengal Folktales reading unit. The original story was called The Ghost Brahman.

The first thing I would like to make sure is clear is that in the story, "Neat-Herd King" is the king or leader of Cow Herders.

The was about a man who went to work in a distant land to earn money for his wife, mother, and himself to live comfortably. However, the day he left, a ghost took his form and convinced the wife and mother that he had decided to stay, thus taking over the Brahman's life. The Brahman returns, rich and ready to be home, only to find that someone who looks identical to him is living his life. He tries to make the ghost leave, but the ghost continues to insist he is the real Brahman. The man then asks the King for help but the King is confused and doesn't know what to do, so he continues putting off the decision. Finally, the Brahman asks for the help of the leader of the cow herders, who tricks the ghost into a small vial and seals it. The Brahman then gets his life back with the ghost successfully locked away. 

For my story, I focused on when the Brahman was trying to convince the Neat-Herd King of his identity and the actions of the Herder King afterwards. I thought the way the herder tricked the ghost was clever and I loved that in the end the lowly cow herder was the one to discover the truth and give the Brahman his life back.

I didn't change much in the story. I did add that the Neat-Herd King had dealt with similar ghosts before because I thought that would better explain how he decided to trick the ghost.

Story source:Folk-Tales of Bengal by the Rev. Lal Behari Day, with illustrations by Warwick Goble (1912).

9 comments:

  1. Good job establishing the setting in the first paragraph and hooking the reader with the instant knowledge that someone literally stole the main character's identity! Great plot.

    In the first sentence I would say "stood with", "stood around with", "stood near," "stood in front of," "stood before" (my favorite) or "stood by". I understand you were using it in the same sense that we say, "hanging around," but it still doesn't quite read right for some reason.

    In the fourth paragraph after the image, I think you ought to remove the comma after "then". I just don't see that the comma does anything for that sentence.

    In the third paragraph down from that one, I noticed you put "the my look alike" on accident. I would just remove "the" (but I'm sure you meant to anyways, lol).

    You capitalized Neat-Herd King in the beginning of the story, but nowhere else throughout the story. I would capitalize it throughout, and capitalize king throughout, since it is capitalized in some areas and lowercased when referring to the neat-herd king.

    Your paragraphs are just right for easy reading, and I like that you did a storytelling post on a myth outside of the Ramayana and Mahabharata, because I have not read many of the other Indian stories we have access to in this class. It is really refreshing to read something completely new to me! This story was very entertaining and I enjoyed it!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I absolutely loved this story. It was very interesting and so different. This poor man just wanted to give his wife and mother a better life and he was replaced by a creepy ghost. The Neat-Herd King was genius in the idea to have the ghost foolishly trap himself. The addition of the king having experience with a ghost before was such a good idea. It really helped everyone understand where he would come up with such a crazy idea.
    I did however notice that in your paragraph that says “… and I told my wife and mother this…” You might want to have that statement followed by a colon as to what exactly he says. Breaking it up in a paragraph makes it seem as if it is a completely separate thought when it is actually a continuation of the previous thought.
    Other than that, I really enjoyed this story!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Kelsey! I really liked your story! Your use of detail was wonderful throughout the entire story. Your dialogue worked to develop your characters. You were straightforward with the readers, letting them know the problem from the beginning. I had sympathy for your character. You showed how difficult it was for him and the frustration involved with having his identity literally stolen from him.

    I was happy that he was reunited with his family in the end – I love a happy ending! I like that the herder was the one to come to the rescue. He was an unlikely hero, but he was clever enough to trick the ghost! And I liked the imagery of the ghost transforming into a bug and flying into the bottle.

    I like that the picture you used helped me to better picture the setting of your story.
    Wonderful job! I m looking forward to reading more of your stories in the coming weeks of class!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kelsey, I thought you did a really great job with this story! You did a great job at setting the story and developing the characters and using dialogue to tell the story. I think your story was very well-written and easy to understand, which kept me interested in the story. I didn't read the original, but I thought your adaptation was so great! I love happy endings, so I thought it a great way to tell the story. I definitely felt sympathetic for your character. I thought your blog design was great too, as well as the picture you included. This set the scene and gave the blog a good feel. The title was also great! Overall, good job with this story and I look forward to reading more from you!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Kelsey,
    I’m immediately wondering ‘what in the world could have happened that resulted in this man’s identity being stolen?’ Good job with getting the reader invested in the story early. I’m intrigued by the idea that this man has left his family in order to find a more viable means of supporting them. This is what many immigrants attempt to do and get chastised for in the United States. What a great twist in the plot! I imagined that the bottle would be used in this fashion – what do you know. I’m interested in knowing how there could actually be a character who herded cattle and was a king in the Bengal Folk Tales. I enjoyed many of the folk tales myself because they were quite a change of pace when compared to the (somewhat) repetitive Ramayana written by Buck. Overall, I thought this was a well written story. Good job.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Kelsey!

    I really enjoyed reading your story. I did not read this unit in the UnTextbook, but you have me convinced by your story that I should read this unit next! I think that your story proves to be original and fun, and is creative as well! I think it is also important to note how true this type of family situation is. Many of the people that I have met whilst traveling in India thus far have relatives, brothers, or fathers who live and work in another city or state, far from their family. So, I find it interesting that such an aged fairy tale even sheds light onto modern times. Poverty still drives people to give up their families and move far away in order to work to earn money for them. It is such a sad predicament! But, I really enjoyed your story. I look forward to reading more of them!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Kelsey,

    When first reading your story I was a little confused on what was going on. I of course assumed that your story was going to be about one of the epics, but then I remembered that we were allowed to read some of the Un-Texbook for a few of the weeks. This story is well written, and if I have not said it before you are a creative and talented writer. I didn't see anything that I could really critique on. The flow of the text makes it easy for a reader to keep track, and there is more than enough information to prevent the reader from becoming confused on any part of the tale. It was more than nice to have read a retelling that was not inspired by one of the epics. I have not read a story, before, where a ghost has taken over the life of a human, and I have really enjoyed it! Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I was able to read this folktale so it was really fun hearing your rendition of it! You stuck to the storyline really well. Also, your author’s note is great. The summary was well written and important since some of your audience may not have read the story. I like how you clarified who the Neat-Herd King was because that was one thing that confused me while I was reading the folktale.

    It might have been fun to add a few more little twists to the story. Your addition of the Neat-Herd King having experience with tricking ghosts before is a great example of how you added a small twist. Maybe the Brahman could have a side story of his adventures while he is away.

    Overall I think your writing is great!

    One correction I found is the first sentence of your second paragraph in your author’s note. I think you meant to say “This story was about a man…”

    ReplyDelete
  9. Kelsey,

    This story is very interesting. I was not able to read this story in the folk books but it seems like a great story. I really enjoyed some of the aspects of the story such as the king having past experience with ghosts. Also, for not having read the original story I felt I was able to still follow this easily and you portrayed all the details very well. Nicely done overall.

    ReplyDelete