Showing posts with label Week 4. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Week 4. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 3, 2015

Week 4: The Boy in the Forest (Storytelling)

I watched as Dasaratha slept. His wife, Kausalya, sat nearby. The old king shifted and tensed in his sleep. I knew he was remembering me.  The night that ended with him burning the bodies of my parents and me.

I wished, for his sake, that he didn’t have to go through losing a son. I had seen what it did to my parents. When he killed me, it had been an accident. But Rama’s exile was not one. Kaikeyi’s spite and fear had poisoned her husband’s spirit. He would be dead by morning.

I thought back to that night, so many decades before. When the king was a prince and I was just a child. That night contained many mixed memories for me. Obviously, my death and watching my parents mourn and die was not a happy occasion. However, when Indra welcomed me into the Heaven of Warriors, well that was an amazing. It wasn’t long before my parents joined me, with their eyes and bodies repaired.  I thanked Dasaratha for that every day. He could have left my parents to die slowly, wondering what had become of me. But he was a good man, one who made a mistake but tried to fix it as best he could.

Everything had changed so suddenly that night. It had been a normal day. My mother wanted water before bed. I usually don’t like going out at night, but the sun had just set and the river wasn’t far. I’d taken our water jar, and after kissing my mother and father, I promised to return shortly, I left my home for the last time. After a short walk, I knelt down and dipped the jar into the river. Branches crunched to my left and I began to stand, turning towards the sound. Before I was upright, I saw something flying at me and felt the pain through my chest. Next thing I knew I was lying in the dirt, looking up at the stars.

“Who has killed me!?” I cried out, answered only by silence. Then footsteps began coming towards me. In the moonlight stood the prince, Dasaratha, looking pale and shaking.

He stared for a moment, as his face turned a sickly shade of green and tears filled his eyes. He didn’t speak, but stood, staring at what he had done to me. “Prince Dasaratha, have I wronged you in some way that made you want me dead? My parents will now die too. They are blind and sick, unable to move. They have never hurt anyone. Take out the arrow you have killed me with.” Even as I spoke I could feel my life slipping away.

The prince approached me, leaning down to examine the wound. I couldn’t see it, but I knew it was bad. “If I take it out,” he said slowly, “You will die. I’ll leave it in and go find a doctor.”
He began to stand but I grabbed his wrist with the last of my strength. “I’m not afraid of death. I don’t curse you, it was an accident. But please release me. It’s too painful.” Dasaratha did as I asked and pulled out the arrow.

 Soon I was soaring to heaven, being welcomed by Indra. “Child,” the god said, “You have died a warrior’s death.  Come and rest now.” I watched as the prince found my parents, told them what he’d done and carried them to my body. They saw me in the sky one last time before they died as well.

I knew that Dasaratha’s mistake would cost him dearly. That’s how everything works. You get returned what you give. But as I watch him wake and tell Kausalya my story, it feels unfair that a mistake would be answered by maliciously exiling the son he loved so dearly.
Dasharatha and the Blind Boy's Family. Wikimedia.

Author's Note: I kept the story mostly the same, but changed it to the perspective to that of the boy, watching from heaven as Dasaratha lost Rama and remembered that night in the forest. Besides the point of view change, most of the original story was kept the same, with only some wording differences. I decided to expand beyond just the actual event when Dasaratha accidentally kills the boy to connect it to Rama's exile and Dasaratha's reaction. Because the boy and the parents were so understanding of Dasaratha's mistake, I thought that when the karma came back to Dasaratha, the boy and his parents would be sympathetic to Dasaratha's situation.

One reason I decided to use this story was because I thought the part in the story when Dasaratha sees the boy's soul's path going to heaven and being accepted into the heaven of heroes was a really cool touch to the story. I also chose this story because it is a great example of how karma works in Indian tradition. Lastly, it also explains Dasaratha's behavior after Rama is exiled, which in Naryayan's story, without the inclusion of the sotry of the Boy in the Forest, seemed a little overly dramatic.


Bibiography: Buck, William (1976). Ramayana: King Rama's Way. P. 105-109

Week 4: Rama's Exile (Reading Diary B)

One thing that I liked more about Buck's version of Ramayana as opposed to Narayan's was how they came to decide Rama should be made king. In Narayan's the decision was made secretly and sneakily while making sure Bharata was away, as though to limit Rama's competition. This seemed kind of low to me, especially when you see how Bharata reacts to his mother's schemes, that they should try to push him out of the way before crowning Rama. I liked that in Buck's version, it wasn't because Bharata was away that the king decides to make Rama king, but because of some special astrological occurrence, they decide to crown Rama, saying that it would be better if his brothers were here but it was a unique occurrence that would favor the event.

While Kaikeyi's betrayal of Rama happened much in the same way as in Narayan, because of the servant making her fear for her and Bharata's lives once Rama took the crown, Buck's version portrays Kaikeyi as much more conniving and self-serving. This was very apparent in the story about Kaikeyi trying to convince Dasharatha to teach her the language of animals, something he had sworn to never do. Even after being told that Dasharatha would die immediately after, if he ever told anyone, she still pushed him to teach her, knowing it would be his end.

I couldn't believe that Dasharatha took it as far as he did, by building his own funeral pyre to be burned on after he told Kaikeyi the secret, and she was alright with that, sitting on the funeral pyre, waiting for the secret and her husband to die. If he hadn't heard the animals, she would have let him kill himself to give up his secret knowledge. After that incident, I feel like the smartest thing to do would be to keep the king away from Kaikeyi as much as possible, because she obviously had too much power over him. Having this first incident included in the story, before Kaikeyi makes Dasharatha exile Rama and make Bharata king, made her character much less sympathetic, as obviously she didn't care about the king.

Much of the exile story is very similar to Narayan's, with only a few small differences. I did like the extra stories, like about Kaikeyi from Gahu, I also liked the extra back story behind Dasharatha's death, with the boy he killed in the forest. It seemed much more believable that that would cause him grief than just his son leaving when he would return after his exile.
Dasharatha and the Blind Boy's Family. Wikimedia.

Week 4: Rama/Sita Relationship and Ravana's History (Reading Diary A)

It was really interesting, starting this new version of Ramayana and seeing how differently Buck and Narayan translate the stories. The details they keep in or add can change the story quite a lot.

In the very beginning, when Rama has exiled Sita while she is pregnant with twins seemed so strange to me. So much of the love story of Rama and Sita focuses on how perfect they are together and how they are meant to be. But between exiling his pregnant wife at the beginning of Buck's version, and in Narayan's version after he rescues her, telling her he doesn't trust her and to leave, causing her to jump on pyre, I don't know how his behavior towards her is very romantic or soul mate-ish. Although there are other parts in the stories where they do seem perfect together, there are some sections that just don't seem to fit nicely into the story or reflect very well on Rama's feelings towards Sita. 


I loved learning more about Ravana's beginnings, as well as some of the other Rakshasas. They all have very interesting back stories and I like that Buck included more about them than Narayan. One part in particular that stuck out to me about Ravana's back story is when everyone else had given up to him, but the King Kartavirya, who had been bathing when Ravana attacked just started squeezing him with a some of his many arms until Ravana had to be saved by his family. This was a very different version of Ravana's story than we saw in Narayan's tellings where Ravana is usually thought to be all powerful. 
Arjuna humbles Ravana. Wikimedia